Have you ever found yourself staring at a creative idea – whether it’s a campaign concept, a draft proposal, or the notes from a brainstorm and thinking, “Is this actually any good?”
If so, you’re not alone. This episode of the Now Go Create podcast is the one I wish I’d had years ago when I first started reviewing creative work. Judging creativity is both art and science, an emotional and a rational act. But with the right tools, we can move beyond gut reactions and personal bias to evaluate creative work with clarity, consistency, and confidence. Whether you’re a creative director, a comms lead, or part of an in-house marketing team, this blog distills the key takeaways and frameworks from the episode including insights from leading PR creatives and strategists I interviewed.
Why judging creativity is so damn hard
Creative work is subjective by nature. As the IPA puts it, judging creativity is where instinct meets intellect. One person’s “brave” is another’s “off-brand.” The stakes are high – what if you make the ‘wrong’ decision for the business or the execution doesn’t deliver how you thought/predicted/hoped it would.
But here’s the good news: there are tools to help. I’m sharing five proven frameworks from my creative kitbag you can use to assess ideas more objectively plus street-smart wisdom from fellow Creative Moment Awards judges Kim Allain (Golin), Greg Double (Burson), and Gemma Moroney (SHOOK).
Head vs heart: why your first reaction is emotional
“The key question is never what the idea is, but what the idea has to do.” – Dean Poole, Creative Director, Alt Group
Think about the last time you thought something was creative. What was it, and what criteria did you use to decide? For me, it’s often the envy factor – when I think, “ooh, I wish I’d thought of that!”
Whilst we like to think we’re being rational, our first reaction is almost always emotional: fast, intuitive and unconscious, as Daniel Kahneman brilliantly summarised in Thinking, Fast and Slow. In The Rough Guide to the Brain, Barry J Gibb puts it like this: as the mind moves through possible choices, “it is the emotions that give the thumbs up or down”.
That’s not a bad thing. Gut feel is useful data. But it shouldn’t be the only data – which is exactly why the frameworks below help. (Parts of this section come from my book In Your Creative Element, reproduced with permission from Kogan Page.)
Dreamer, realist or critic? Judge at the right time
I once asked a group of workshop delegates to evaluate some creative work. Whilst we encourage critical thinking, I was surprised by the vigour with which they ripped it apart! They dived straight into what was “wrong”, rather than what they could learn from it.
Walt Disney’s creative process famously had three distinct roles: the dreamer, the realist and the critic. The story goes that Disney only adopted one mindset at a time, working through the stages until an idea was robust enough to stand up to the critic. Jump straight to critic – or what Edward de Bono calls black-hat thinking – and you can kill the seed of an idea before it ever sees daylight.
Mindset matters too. Stanford’s Carol Dweck describes “fixed” and “growth” mindsets: people with a growth mindset learn from criticism and keep going in the face of setbacks, while a fixed mindset treats feedback as a threat. Teams that judge ideas well tend to have the growth version.
What makes a good idea?
Before you reach for a framework, it helps to agree what “good” looks like. A few definitions I love:
- WPP agency Millward Brown describes a big idea as a game-changer that turns category convention on its head. It should resonate, be disruptive, have talk value, travel across cultures and stretch the brand without straining credibility.
- John Whiston, ITV’s former creative director of continuing drama (Coronation Street, Emmerdale), told me a good idea is all about heart: “when you hear it, it has the same effect on you as a good joke… It makes you gasp a bit”. You can drag a wild idea back in with intellect and craft – but you can’t push a so-so idea to greatness.
Now let’s make that judgement more objective, with five frameworks from my creative kitbag.
Framework 1: the Heineken Creative Ladder
Use it for: evaluating ambition and originality
Created by Arif Haq working with Heineken, when he worked at Contagious, the creative ladder is a 10-step “dictionary” to help you articulate how strong an idea really is from clichéd to legendary. I interviewed Haq about it for my book back in 2016 and it really is a brilliant tool to help you to frame conversations about creativity, set a benchmark and challenge yourself and others to a higher standard. It works from 1-10.
You can’t jump to ‘legendary’ without passing through ‘ownable’ and ‘fresh’. The ladder helps teams build shared language, level out subjective opinions, and even bridge the gap between creatives and clients. Five is considered the minimum standard for Heineken and its agencies as the benchmark for creative work.
10 Legendary
9 Cultural phenomenon
8 Contagious
7 Groundbreaking
6 Fresh
5 Ownable
4 Cliché
3 Fusing
2 Hijacked
1 Destructive
As Haq says: “It gives you objective scaffolding for your subjective opinion.”
Framework 2: IDEO’s lifeline cards
Use it for: reviewing work from multiple human-centred angles
The design lifeline cards from IDEO are a powerful tool to reframe and review creative work using seven lenses:
- Heart – does it come from a place of empathy?
- Beauty – is it elegant, iconic, evocative?
- Brains – is it strategic and novel?
- Bravery – did it take risks?
- Magic – is there awe or delight?
- Mastery – is there evidence of craft?
- Destiny – will it create long-term impact?
Pro tip: use these cards at any stage of the process – briefing, reviewing, or final evaluation. They’re like a Swiss army knife for creative conversations.
Download the cards here. They are a gift 😉 Print them off and share with your team.
Framework 3: James Hurman’s creative effectiveness code
Use it for: understanding the commercial impact of your ideas
This model focuses on the effectiveness of creativity through six levels, from basic behavioural influence to full-on brand fame:
- Influences behaviour
- Changes perception
- Drives short-term sales
- Builds long-term growth
- Creates cultural impact
- Achieves brand fame
Insight: This code helps you map your idea against commercial objectives and work towards meaningful results. I’ve merely scratched the surface, so grab a cuppa, sit down and read the full deck here. They analysed and compared a total of 4,863 effectiveness award entrants and winners from 2011 through 2019, from every major market in the world, including cases from Cannes Lions and 216 from the IPA databank. You can’t say I’m not good to you 😉
Framework 4: the evaluation matrix
Use it for: comparing well-formed ideas against agreed criteria
A systematic tool from the Creative Problem Solving process. List your ideas down the left-hand side and your criteria along the top (budget, brand fit, impact, timing – whatever matters for this brief). Pick a scoring system, such as 0–10.
The trick: score down the columns, not across the rows. If you take your favourite idea and score it across every criterion, the halo effect kicks in and it’ll score higher than it deserves (Isaksen et al, 2011). Framing each criterion as a question – “Does this idea deliver x?” – keeps you honest.
Done well, the matrix isn’t just a numbers game. It shows you each idea’s strengths and weaknesses, so you can improve the ideas rather than simply rank them. Edward de Bono’s Six Thinking Hats is another tried-and-tested way to get different perspectives on the same idea.
Framework 5: the murder board
Use it for: stress-testing ideas before they face the client
Borrowed from the CIA (via Michael Michalko’s Thinkertoys): convene a “murder board” of people who’ve had nothing to do with the idea, and ask them to mercilessly critique it, find the holes and bombard you with awkward questions. The aim is to kill an idea that’s fatally flawed – or make it much stronger if it has potential.
It’s brilliant once ideas are well developed and you want an honest, unemotional outside view. It’s not one for the early stages, when ideas are still fragile.
I like to get to three or four well-formed concepts before exposing them to a potentially grisly death. Preparing for a big pitch a few years ago, I set up a war room and invited everyone in the business to pop by for five minutes and add questions and comments to the six ideas pasted on the walls. By the end of the day, those ideas had faced more than 30 potential assassins. We killed a few, revived others – and won the pitch (worth £1m, delivered in 10 slides). I’m sure that level of scrutiny was a big part of it.
What top-of-their game creative directors look for
Here’s what my podcast guests said when asked how they judge great creative work ahead of the Creative Moment Awards:
“Start with insight. Then trust your gut.” – Gemma Moroney, SHOOK
“If it shows up in a non-PR WhatsApp group, it’s probably good.” – Greg Double, Burson
“I look for authenticity and impact beyond our bubble.” – Kim Allain, Golin
And when it comes to writing award entries:
“Don’t just tick boxes, tell a story.” Greg Double
“Make the judges fall in love with the idea.” Gemma Moroney
Listen to the full podcast episode here for all the juicy goodness.
Questions to ask yourself (and your team)
- Do you spend more time as a dreamer, a realist or a critic?
- Are you giving ideas time to breathe before you judge them?
- What criteria are you actually using – and have you agreed them up front?
- Is your team’s mindset closer to fixed or growth when it comes to feedback?
- Where could you bring in a fresh pair of eyes, like a murder board?
Whether you’re judging award entries, pitching to clients, or reviewing internal campaigns, the ability to evaluate creative work is a learnable skill. If your team would benefit from hands-on support to help determine impact, creative workshops or bespoke training, I’d love to help.
Book a discovery call with Now Go Create Founder Claire Bridges – email claire@nowgocreate.co.uk
Want to build these skills in your team? See our Creative Leadership training or book a free 30-minute call with Claire.
Read more: Question-storming: how to interrogate a problem before you solve it